La importancia epistémica de la experimentación en ecología
Abstract
This work aims to analyze epistemologically the different methods from which the ecology obtains knowledge, evidencing the advantages and disadvantages of each one and visualizing a proposal from which the ecology can obtain greater scientific solidity. If the ecologist focuses on the search for patterns, the method that supports it is inductivism, since part of the observation from which it obtains data that it uses to discover regularities in nature. The search for patterns based on a problem and a hypothesis that guides the investigation corresponds to the non-experimental studies, since no treatments are imposed, nor are the variables manipulated under study. This makes it difficult to discover the mechanisms, causes and emergent properties and therefore of the processes that are causing the observed pattern. On the other hand, if the ecologist focuses on the search for processes the method that supports it is the hypothetical deductive as proposed by Mario Bunge, since it seeks to explain the phenomena observed from a mechanistic hypothesis that investigates the causes, why and the how of the pattern observed. To test the mechanistic hypothesis, experiments must be carried out, that is, to manipulate the system in order to discover its operation. Macroecology and landscape ecology have serious difficulties in performing manipulative experiments, and therefore inquiring into the causes of the observed pattern. Faced with this problem, this work proposes a complementarity between the manipulative and non-manipulative studies, which would consist of the realization of natural experiments and the subsequent testing of the results obtained from experiments in the laboratory. Both procedures ensure the discovery of processes in nature and are more realistic, more explanatory and more representational.
